General Hospital Discussion Group -- Oh just shut up Carly!!

General Hospital Discussion Group

Topic: Oh just shut up Carly!!

Topic Posted by: ladfan
Date Posted: Thu Nov 5 17:49:04 2009
Additional Comments:

Carly reamed Jax out for keeping Claudia's involvement a secret, and she was entitled to it. But to blame him for what happened is going overboard. How about her crazy ex-husband who knew the truth and chose to poke that snake in public? Sonny knew how unhinged Claud was and yet chose to humiliate her in public. Or how about Carly's BFF St.Jasus? He knew the truth. Did he run to tell Carly the truth? No. Not only did Jason NOT tell Carly, but acted all innocent when he visited her and found out that she was upset about Jax knowing all along. Punk!! Carly orders her husband out and then tells their baby that he made a big mistake. Will she react the same way when she finds out Jason knew as well?

I need for CarJax to end and NOW!! Run Jax Run!!

Posted by: Ha
Date posted: Fri Nov 6 15:44:32 2009
Message:
You beat me to this post!! You KNOW what an a$$ Car-Liar is....she'll damn Jax all to hell for keeping it from her BUUUTTTTT JaSon will get a *I forgive YOU, NOT my HUB* crapola!!!! She needs to be smacked!! Jax does NOT deserve her...never has!

Replies: (list all replies)

All I want for Jax is a divorce from Carly. ladfan

Posted by: tweety
Date posted: Fri Nov 6 10:36:33 2009
Message:

I'm so with Carly on this one. Jax is a big fat hypocrite. He wants Carly to turn in Michael, yet he knew all about his murderous psycho brother's crimes and never said a word. I love Carly and Jax together, but Jax needs to let go of his Sonny hate now that he is the one Carly loves. But just like he protected his psycho brother all these years, he needs to let Carly do what she thinks is best for her child. He has totally overlooked the fact that Carly chose to tell him the complete truth when she didn't have to. She could have lied to his face like Jax has done over the past several months.

Replies: (list all replies)

I agree that Jax is a hypocrite to want to protect Jerry, even if he did it to protect Carly and his baby. But there was no reason to cover up what Michael did. He did nothing wrong. if Carly truly wanted Michael to stay away from the mob, she would start truing to the law instead of Sason at SOME point. But all I see is her paying lip service to that and carrying on like before. ladfan

Of course the right decision is to have Michael turn himself in and get the help he needs. But my point is that its Carly's decision to make. Jax needs to shut up and let her make it, just like he was allowed to make the decision regarding his psycho brother.

I agree that it is Carly's decision, but that doesn't mean Jax shouldn't talk to her about it. She told him and he said how he felt about the situation. If it were up to me, Jax would be far away from Carly. ladfan

Posted by: SqueezeMe
Date posted: Fri Nov 6 10:33:44 2009
Message:

Hi. I am *not* a Jax hater, and I agree that Carly's decision to cover Michael is not the right one for Michael, but Jax should probably just keep quiet, since his decision to do the same thing for Jerry didn't exactly work out for his family.

As for Jason, if it wasn't Olivia's secret to tell, then I'm giving Jasey a pass. It wasn't his secret to tell either, and IMO he and Jax both had a legitimate reason to delay telling Carly anyway. Jason did, however, try repeatedly to convince Sonny that Claudia was poison, not to be trusted, and probably guilty of some aspect of Michael's shooting; he just didn't have proof.

Replies: (list all replies)

I agree about Jax keeping quiet about Michael and everything else. He should speak when spoken to. You are not seriously comparing Carly's relationship with Jason to the one with Olivia? He is supposedly her BFF and she would put her life on the line for him. He owes her a lot more than Olivia does. As for Jax's status as her husband, it would carry some weight if Carly retruned some of that loyalty. She puts Jason ahead of Jax every time. My point is that Carly will just pat Jason on the head when she finds out he knew too. She can forgive him anything, but not Jax. I guess marriage vows apply only to Jax. ladfan

I think Carly has made a real effort to be truthful with Jax and expects the same from him. She is now as firmly in the Sonny-Jason camp as she ever was (sigh), but I don't think Carly sees that as disloyalty to Jax, and I don't either. Sason are part of the package, and there has never been any question about that. I don't want CarJax to divorce. I want a minimal amount of time with happy Carly/Jax/baby before they blow them up. Then I'm good. Be patient. :o) //SqueezeMe

Posted by: Jean
Date posted: Fri Nov 6 2:07:37 2009
Message:
Carly, Carly, Carly, Carly. It's always all about Carly and how she wants to control everyone around her. About how she feels how everything and everyone should be and feel and act according to how she sees fit. And the darned thing is that she always tries to make it seem as if it is about someone else. For example, in the last few days of her pregnancy she takes off at night and goes to the Metro Court to find Michael so she can make sure he is safe. So she endangers her unborn child by going to Claudia's birthday party even after dire warnings from her obstetrician. And all the little things she did that she wasn't supposed to do during her pregnancy. She had everyone telling her to "stop" and "cut it out" and "please relax" and "please don't stress yourself out" and "don't eat that." When the whole time she does those stupid things for attention. Carly, Carly, Carly, Carly. I'm just sick of Carly!

Replies: (list all replies)

Yup. You nailed it, Jean. Carly is a drama queen and attention hog. What about all her lies and cover ups? We all saw this coming, though, when Jax first started keeping things from Carly in his mind to protect her. Carly has a right to some degree wto be angry with him but it shouldn't last long if she were rational. Carly's still all about cover ups and breaking the law to protect people she loves. Jax prfers to give the law a chance at least. Jax needs to free himself of Carly once and for all, but what about Josslyn? He'll never let go of her so I see a custody battle in the offing. Boring. Helena

*Jax prefers to give the law a chance*?? What? Is that what he was doing with his psycho brother all this time.

Posted by: PhoenixTamer
Date posted: Thu Nov 5 21:39:53 2009
Message:

Hi lf!!!!

You know whaaat???? Do you want to what about it think i think??? ???

Well, ill tell ya!

I most heartedly agree with you on this one!

CarJax needs o get CarJACKED!

I don't like how jasper has been coming off lately and I LOATHE how hypocritical judgemental Carly has been behaving.

I guess it shouldn't be too shocked about wha it though. I mean, despite the fabulous Laura Ws softer portrayal, this IS still Carly.

Shes asked Jax to put up with alot. ALOT. - More than any husband should semi-sanely be asked to put up with.

Forcing himto allow other men like Jason and Sonny (even though he be her babydaddy) in their life...rushing off to them anytime they crook their finger...making Jax feel like Jason and Son can never do any wrong an dtotally be blameless (see: 'kendall heart-slater syndrome)...

Never allowing the poor guy to even get two words out about how sonny handled the entire situation when - as you so asututely pointed up - he forces caludia into a ''Do Something Crazy or Die'' situation by absurdly exposing her in that public setting.

I like Car Lee. I LOVE Laura Wright.

But lately I have to ask her...''Where O Where Do You Be Gettin Off, You Total BEE-OUCH???!!!''

Chris/pt

Replies: (list all replies)

I also like Laura Wright, but even she can't make me like Carly. I loathe and detest that witch. My Jax, stuck with her. ladfan

Posted by: Vivian Daniels
Date posted: Thu Nov 5 20:25:03 2009
Message:
I was so glad when she kicked that scumbag out of her room today. And told him she wanted to talk to Jason alone, I just wished that Sonny was there too with Jason and holding Jocelyn in front of Jax.

Posted by: Vivian Daniels
Date posted: Thu Nov 5 20:21:33 2009
Message:
Jason had an idea that Claudia/Jerry/Ian was behind Michael's shooting. But he didn't have proof until recently. But would've told her if she hadn't been pregnant as soon as he had definate proof.

Replies: (list all replies)

So, Jason is right if he doesn't tell Carly because she is pregnant, but Jax is wrong? I don't get it. ladfan

Apparently there are double standards for characters on GH. For Claudia to be a mobster is wrong but for Sonny it's right. For Jax to lie to protect Carly is wrong, but for Jason to do it is right. Blah blah effing blah. Helena

Without debating when, I agree that both Jason and Jax had a duty to tell Carly. But I do think Jax's duty was higher, given that he and Carly are married. I know Jason is her BFF and all, but Carly and Jason haven't taken vows. Is that old fashioned? //SqueezeMe

Sm, Carly was probably thinking of Jason when she said her vows anyway :) ladfan

I will give you this: they have been looking *very* married. //SM

Posted by: Helena
Date posted: Thu Nov 5 20:09:24 2009
Message:
Her other BFF, Oblivia also knew and never told her. I couldn't believe Jason pretended he didn't know about it, too, when he visited Carly. I'll be so bored if she's stupid enough to dump Jax over this. But sadly, I see CarSon will be revisited not long from now and Sonny will be the one holding Josslyn in his arms. I suppose he'll adopt her, too, like the boy he's ruined. But it will have to be over Jax's dead body.

Replies: (list all replies)

Actually, I give a pass just this once for Olivia. It is not her secret, she found out because she overheard Jax. Jax is wrong no matter what, but in this case, he had good intentions, but he is still wrong. ladfan

Nope, no pass for Olivia who's known the longest and acts all gooey for Sonny and seems Carly's only girlfriend. All this time she's kept her knowledge of Claudia's part in Michael's shooting a secret from two people who really trust her and one she wants to pork, no less, father of her son, and if she gets off scott free I'll be pissed. Can you tell I don't like her? :) Helena

I loathe Olivia, but she has no more loyalty than Sonny and Jason to Carly. From what I have seen, she is friends with both Jax and Carly. Jax is keeping her secret and she is keeping his. Yes, she should have told Carly, but she has her reasons. ladfan

Is that stupid SL goes....this show needs to be cancelled.