Topic Posted by: Sue
Date Posted: Mon May 12 10:08:12 2008
Additional Comments: Does anyone here monitor their kids texting, IMing or e-mails? I have and I have decided to eliminate this form of communicating. There have been things typed that I don't think would have been said. Inappropriate things. I think the technology has eliminated the natural barriers people have like shyness, and it's not good - especially for teens. Things will naturally happen at their own rate. This type of bold communication which can also be shared with unintended recipients doesn't seem like a good thing to me - as a parent.
Posted by: Grandma b@s Date posted: Tue May 13 2:27:31 2008
Message:
Sue, Check into a internet monitoring software http://www.safecomputerkids.com/ . We did use them for our kids. They KNEW I snooped and they knew I knew how to find history they tried to hide. That's just part of the privilege of having a computer and/or getting to use the internet. These programs run in the background and most of the time the kids don't even know they are there. With these programs you can go in and find out what the kids are doing online (whether they delete them or not).. I didn't check often but the kids never knew when I was going to check. If I did, and there was something I didn't think they should be saying, I would confront them. Yeah, they would be upset that I snooped, but I'd discuss it with them.
Just chatting, cussing, etc, I'd just let that go. We used to pass NOTES when I was in school and so that 'outsiders' wouldn't know what we were talking about, we talked in a code that we made up. People had 'NICKNAMES'. We never signed out REAL names, we would use names that not all that different than screen names. As for the CONSTANT COMMUNICATION, I remember sitting for HOURS on the phone, often not saying anything. And I know that even when we were together, we'd say things that our parents never knew about. And realistically, I doubt that anything they are saying when they are texting, IMing, etc.. is not all that different than stuff they would say in person anyway.
My suggestion is tell your daughter you snooped, let her know that you check up on her. Limit her texting (there are ways to do that with most cell phone companies as well). If she knows you are checking on her and if she even thinks you might be monitoring her, she may delete emails for a while but she'll get tired of deleting or forget. (especially if you do get one of the net monitoring programs).
Oh, I'm rambling a bit. I hope you understand what I'm getting at. Don't feel bad for snooping, it's your JOB. But unless her emails/texts/IMs are dangerous in some way, just let it go.
Posted by: Shea Date posted: Mon May 12 20:24:08 2008
Message: Limit, but do not forbid. Why so extreme? I'm old enough to be a grandma, but I remember being a kid, and it was not easy. I understand your concerns. Discuss them with her. Cyber-bullying is a real and large problem, and girls are very very good at this type of behavior. She is not going to like that you snooped. Try to get past that and open up the lines of communication about what is appropriate to you and what is not and find out what she is thinking and feeling. Make it plain you want what is best for her. But don't alienate her completely from technology. It is a valuable social and educational tool. Help teach her to use it correctly.
Posted by: starfish Date posted: Mon May 12 15:36:48 2008
Message: Maybe this could be a compromise: nix the texting and IM which, as you pointed out, is overdone and intrudes on other areas of life. Allow her to continue with email (it could help with developing writing and keyboarding skills), but limit the amount of time she spends on the computer.
Posted by: ingyandbert Date posted: Mon May 12 12:13:05 2008
Message:
IMO, taking away those forms of communication althogether is only going to backfire on you by making you look unreasonable and stirring resentment. The better approach might be to treat it as a privilege that can be earned back through proper behavior. Give the kid something to work toward and learn to use it responsibly.
Posted by: DixuhsBaybuh Date posted: Mon May 12 11:58:09 2008
Message:
Sounds good to me, let them learn how to talk. IM's and texts are brainless jibber jabber. Banning e-mail altogether probably is not a great idea because writing a good letter is a valuable skill. Eventually they may do that. I don't have kids but I remember being one. We wrote letters and notes, e-mail just sends it cleaner and faster.
Hopefully in college they still teach how to calculate, etc.. without a computer as well as with one. I know I did at Ga. Tech, and we had access to leading edge technology but we still did most of it by hand, pencil, and brain.