Soap Opera Discussion Groups and Forums

All My Children Discussion Group

Topic: Who Would Love For Cady McClain To Return To AMC As Dixie????


Topic Posted by: Vivian Daniels
Date Posted: Sat Oct 24 5:17:41 2009
Additional Comments: I would. It'll be nice to have her to reunite with Tad, Jr., and Kathy and for them to be one big happy family. And if this happens I will start watching again. TPTB, please bring her back ok. Cool!!!



Add a MessageGuidelinesTopics ListHomeOther SoapsDaily Recaps for the Show!Registration
Posted by: Claudine
Date posted: Wed Oct 28 10:21:10 2009
Message:

Well, I'd love it. It would be the only thing to get me to tune back in. Haven't watched since GhostDixie disappeared the last time.

Cady did not leave AMC or ATWT of her own volition the last few times. AMC killed her off with PB Pancakes after she spoke up behind the scenes about Tad being a torturer when MMT thought her story was brilliant. She did publically support the story in a magazine interview, as I recall, but was worried for his character and how Tad would fare in the aftermath if he showed no remorse or self-torture over killing Madden (accidentally). ATWT brought her back only to destroy Rosanna for the Paul/Meg stuff and used her short term, then AMC brought her on for a few weeks as a ghost only, and now same with ATWT, 6 months while Maura West was on maternity leave. IMHO it's to her credit that she has a talent as well as a following that shows want and so hire her repeatedly.

My problem is... no one is in character, judging by scoops I read, and the show sucks in general. So do I really want Cady subjected to this bullpoop again? I know I'd enjoy seeing Dixie again, but am afraid of what fresh hell they'd devise for the character.


Respond to this message


Posted by: Ann Marie
Date posted: Tue Oct 27 20:28:23 2009
Message:

I do.  But I don't think the show deserves Tad and Dixie.  The fans do, but the show wouldn't do them justice. 

It's was so wrong that Dixie was killed off the way she was and never got to know the little girl she wanted so badly.  And the Tad and Dixie fans wanted them to have a baby together for so long -- and this is what the writers do?!  Not only that, they stick the knife in and twist it even more by having Tad have a baby girl with Krystal.

I am so angry at Frons and company.  It's been over two years that Dixie was killed off.  They pull something like this and they say it was a mistake in the press, but meanwhile, they have done ZERO to fix it.  And they've had so many chances, they just won't do it.  They don't care.

While I'll always be a fan of All My Children in general, I don't watch the show anymore.  The show doesn't deserve my veiwership at all.


Respond to this message


Posted by: Mouse
Date posted: Mon Oct 26 15:53:41 2009
Message:

It wasn't that she supported Julia Barr in the blog (although i really did admire here for that).

The actress is a bit of a flake / loon and became more and more difficult to work with, hence, the dismissal.

Replies: (list all replies)

  • She is very out there. that's for sure. Notice how neither AMC nor ATWT wanted to extend her contracts? That says alot about how unwilling they are to put up with her wierdness.

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Rosebud1
    Date posted: Sun Oct 25 10:38:09 2009
    Message:
    No!  Absolutely not.

    Even if the show was staying in NYC, I wouldn't want that flake back.  I don't see her making the commute, or signing on for a stint making the commute worth it anyway.  It is one thing to change shows when it is a matter of a short commute, but 3,000 miles is a bit much.

    Personal feelings about Cady aside, I don't think that TPTB at ABC/Disney has done anything for either the actress or the character the last couple of stints.  I liked both Cady & the character of Dixie, but TPTB at ABC did a real number on the character over the last few yrs.  Unless there was a big change in how they interpret the character I wouldn't want to see her back on the canvas. 

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • You have no idea what the actress would want to do! Please don't speak for her.
  • Tyler: I'm NOT speaking for Cady. I'm simply going by her track record & public statements. eom

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Vivian
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 16:47:32 2009
    Message:

    They never seem to know how to put a good storyline together whenever they bring someone back.  I’ve never liked any of her storylines any time they’ve brought her back, or most of the others for that matter.  Look what they did with RB.

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • They were doing okay by Dixie until she supported Julia Barr in her blog..and then they fed her the pancakes! SORAS

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: MamaMia
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 16:15:03 2009
    Message:
    I hope she doesn't make yet another return engagement.  I never thought she and Tad were soulmates anyway and her last appearance IMO was horrible.

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • My darling Tad thinks they are and while I never liked Dixie before...I always said if Tad loves her, then I'll support him in that since his happiness is more important than my opinion. However this last return...they started out on something good (the writers that is) and then Cady supported Julia and out came the pancakes. She's Kate's mother...and I'd like her back with Kate/Kathy and Tad...KWAK be damned. SORAS
  • I'd love for Brooke to come back. They never mention her. MM
  • I doubt that we'll be seeing Brooke back anytime soon. The actress has family & is NYC based. I doubt that, given the way she was treated the last few yrs she was on the show, that she would return no matter where they taped the show. There was talk of JM (Palmer) moving back to LA (or somewhere in CA), but I don't think that will get TPTB to bring Palmer back. eom

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Donata
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 13:18:21 2009
    Message:

    At first when Dixie came on, and she enticed Adam, broke up the best marriage (to Brooke) he ever had....I hated her, but when she got with Tad, I fell in love with the couple.  Then found out she was flighty, would leave the program when ever she pleased... then come back a couple of time, and when she stipulated she wanted to work with David........... that was it for me.  I no longer care for her, and believe if she came back...she would end up leaving once again...she is not really committed to AMC, and comes and goes at will.   So NO, I do not want her to return!  Being that it is now the understanding that Greens will be back when they make the move to California, I believe she is the one that David is taking care of, not Dixie!

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • yeah most likely it's BORING Greenlee..but hey..Cady did not CHOOSE to leave this last time...they killed Dixie off when Cady supported Julia Barr in an exquisitely written piece on her blog. I never read her blog until that happened and then I read what she wrote..it was wonderful. Anyway..THAT'S why Cady was shown the door this last time...she opened her mouth in a wonderfully written way...it was a well reasoned, beautifully stated statement in support of Julia and other women of a certain age...and TPTB slapped her in the face with a poison pancake! She did not choose to leave AMC. SORAS

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: jeanne
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 13:14:38 2009
    Message:
    Why bring her back to be with Tad, then the lies, secrets, cheating will just start all over again. Last time she came back from the grave all she did was lust after Zach, she wasn't all that into Tad. The one good thing she did was rile up Kendall that was fun.

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: acidbrat
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 12:16:16 2009
    Message:
    I'd probably watch more if they brought Dixie back. I'd love to see her help JR through his battle against cancer.

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • Oh, I would definitely start watching again if Cady return to have Dixie reunite with Tad -- the way it SHOULD have happened two years ago before MMT ruined everything. I will never forgive that woman for writing such a horrible story. eom

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: ...
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 10:21:59 2009
    Message:
    Who are you Vivian Daniels?  And why are you going from board to board with questions that have been asked and answered at least a thousand times?

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • I think it's funny that you questioned Vivian Daniels' identity, yet YOUR name is ''...'' -- acidbrat ;-)
  • And would you know her if she told you who she is? So what does it matter! /eom - jinx
  • Many people post something that's already been posted, discussed, etc...it happens...sometimes it's weeks apart..sometimes it's higher up on the board and not noticed...so what..do you think Vivian is Cady? LOL...if so, WELCOME TO THE BOARD, CADY...! LOL...SORAS

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Phoebe Tyler
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 10:08:50 2009
    Message:
    Heck NO!  The character is dead and the actress is as loony as a bird.  She doesn't need to come back, get bored in 2 months then leave again.  Stay away Cady!

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • Bite your tongue, Phoebe...Cady did not CHOOSE to leave this last time......she supported Julia Barr in her blog..and TPTB slapped her with the poison pancakes. SORAS

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: SORAS
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 8:57:02 2009
    Message:

    ME ME ME ME ME!

    As Dixie's last reincarnation, yes...not the pita whiny brat she was before she went off to France and 'died.'

    Yes..I would love for her to be being kept alive by David.

    I'd love for her to return and kick KWAK's backside so far away from Tad and "Kathy" ....Tad can either keep custody of Jenny or send the child off with KWAK...but I would love for Tad to be together forever with Dixie again.

    Then maybe the writers will get Tad back out of the house and into a job outside the home.  I don't care that he's chosen to be a full-time father...I care that he isn't really given much to show he's doing that..and in fact he leaves the kids with (?) at the drop of a hat.  He invited disgusting KWAK back into the home to help raise the girls but KWAK spends 99% of her time bopping around town, usually in some tacky ho-outfit, and 9 times out of 10 ends up at Fusion belting back a few.  BLEH.

    I cannot take Tad with KWAK.  So clear the decks and bring back Dixie and since Dr. Joe is officially gone, let T&D take over as the "stable" couple in town.  Not boring...not senior citizens...just a stable married couple...that does NOT mean boring.  It never did back in the glory days of AMC.  They can have interesting storylines around their jobs, around their children, around other family members and friends...there's a lot of stuff they could mine to make them interesting and up and running characters.

    Yep...bring her back.  That they fired her over the Julia Barr thing was sickening.

    Love Cady..she handled all of that with such professionalism and class.  Bring her back.

    BRING BACK DIXIE (and only Cady can play the role).

     PS:  AND I STILL WISH THEY'D FIND A WAY FOR 'KATHY' TO WANT TO BE CALLED 'KATE'..kids of school age...especially pre-teens although she's not a pre-teen yet and they shouldn't SORAS her to be one either...but even young children often asked to be called other names.  "Junior" asked to be called "JR"..."Kate" (Tara's daughter) asked to be called "Kelsey" ---I don't think that Kathy is too young to say (having been told again the story of her birth) that she'd like to be called "Kate."  I really want that child to be called "Kate" - it has such historic meaning with AMC and it IS the name Dixie gave her to honor Tad's grandmother.  A name is a name but in this case, they need to make the change.


    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Angela
    Date posted: Sat Oct 24 7:32:29 2009
    Message:
    I think it maybe a good idea if they had a great storyline for her return but AMC had so chances  with this character and I think they blew it. 

    Respond to this message


    Add a MessageGuidelinesTopics ListHomeOther SoapsDaily Recaps for the Show!Registration